Monday, May 16, 2016

Chiune Sugihara


After reading Passage to Freedom and watching the video clip above, in what ways are Marcelle Solliage and Chiune Sugihara similar and different?  Use specific details from the stories to defend yourself.

59 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  2. They are similar because they both did thing to free at least 1 Jew and they are different because Chiune helped thousands of people and Marcelle helped 4.

    ReplyDelete
  3. They are similar but different in some ways. They both helped save Jewish's lives. Marcelle Solliage helped the lives of Sevrine and her family. She hid them in her cellar/basement. Chiune Sugihara didn't hide Jews but he did sign visas that helped many people go to a safe country. They both helped Jewish people but they did it in different ways.

    ReplyDelete
  4. But Chiune and a girl named Marcelle are alike because they both helped many Jews. Marelle is different because she helped at least 3-4 Jews and Chiune helped many hundreds of Jews.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Marcelle and Chiune both helped saved Jewish people. Chiune gave out visa but Marcelle sent Jews in a car.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Marcelle and Chiune are very much the same. They both have the determination to help Jewish people escape,but they helped them in diffrent ways. Chiune helped them by writing visas so that they could get to Japan. Marcelle helped them by taking a couple Jewish families to other places where they could be helped.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Marcelle Soliage and Chiune Sugihara are very similar because they both helped Jews and very strongly disliked Nazis. They are different because Chiune Sugihara provided visas to Jews. Marcelle Soliage kept Jews hidden.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Marcelle Soliage and Chiune Sugihara both saved Jews and also let the Jews into their homes. They both also have children. Chiune Soliare saved more than one Jewish family but Marcelle only saved one family. Marcelle and Chiune both are not Jewish. They also lived in diffrent countries.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Marcelle is different from Chiune because she lives in a another country and became friends with one of the Jews escape. Chuine helped hundreds of Jews by giving VISA's to them.

    ReplyDelete
  11. is it because Chiune Sugihara was in or isit because he was in war

    ReplyDelete
  12. They are brave pepL to heLp the jows they helped more then 2 they helped them because they felt sad for them so they mayd a difrents

    ReplyDelete
  13. The son helped them because of the people. The dad had a hard choice of which he should keep his family safe or help the people out. He did what god wanted to do which is help the thousands of people.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I think that they are the same because they both helped jews to be safe and escape the nazis.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. they were both Jewish and wanted to help people. but they helped in different ways and they came from diffrent countrys.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  18. they are the same and different in many ways, such as they both helped jews escape from the Nazi's in different ways like how Chiune made visa's for the jews to use to escape. Marcelle helped hide a jew family in her basement.

    ReplyDelete
  19. i agree with jack perry

    ReplyDelete
  20. is it because Chiune Sugihara was in or isit because he was in war

    ReplyDelete
  21. Marcelle and Chiune are similar and different in many ways. One way Marcelle and Chiune are alike is they both risked their lives to help Jewish refugees. Marcelle helped Jewish refugees by hiding them in her basement. Chiune helped Jewish refugees by wrighting them Visa's without the permission by the Japanese Government. Another way they are alike is both of these exceptional people tried to protect their family while helping the refugees. Marcelle tried to protect her child by not telling her about the refugees in their basement. Chiune tried to protect his family by refusing to let anyone but him sign the Visa's. One way these two amazing people are different is Marceel actualy lead one of the people she was helping, however the people Chiune was helping had to go on their journey on their own. Both of these extrordinary people risked their life to help Jewish refugees.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Chiune Sugihara and Marcelle Solliage are similar because they were both helping Jews but they were different because Marcelle Solliage was french and Chiune Sugihara was Japanese. Marcelle Solliage helped a few Jews at a time and Chiune Sugihara helped hundreds at a time.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Marcelle Solliage and Chiune Sugihara are both helpful and caring people, that makes a them a little bit the alike. This is because they both helped hide and move the Jews from place to place so the Nazi's wouldn't be able to get them. They are different because Chiune asked the government 3 times and they said "No," but Marcelle didn't ask the government because they would come to there house and take them to camps. Also, Marcelle toke them to the train station and Chiune just gave them visa. All of these reasons are why they are alike and different.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Marcelle Solliage and Chiune Sugihara are similar and different from each other. Some similarities between Marcelle Solliage and Chiune Sugihara are that they were both a hero. Marcelle Solliage saved peoples lives because she hid some Jewish people under her house which was under a rug. Chiune Sugihara asked the goveronment if he could give visas to the Jewish people who lived in Lithuania. The government said NO. Chiune Sugihara asked them 3 times but it was still a NO. He didn´t listen to the government and gave all the Jews a visa. Some differences between Marcelle Solliage and Chiune Sugihara are that one of them went to jail the other one didn´t. The government found out what Chiune Sugihara did and he went to jail. On the other hand what Marcelle Solliage did wasn´t known. She kept it as a secret with her daughter and know one ever knew.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Marcelle Solliage and Chiune Sugihara are both helpful and caring people, that makes a them a little bit the alike. This is because they both helped hide and move the Jews from place to place so the Nazi's wouldn't be able to get them. They are different because Chiune asked the government 3 times and they said "No," but Marcelle didn't ask the government because they would come to there house and take them to camps. Also, Marcelle toke them to the train station and Chiune just gave them visa. All of these reasons are why they are alike and different.

    ReplyDelete
  26. They both helped the Jews esacape form the nazi.They both disliked the nazi. they both cared for there family. they both had childeren. These people are the same in these ways.

    ReplyDelete
  27. They are both the same because they thought the people in charge were doing something rong. About the things they were doing and they decided they needed to change it.So they both helped the jews in several ways either hiding them or sending them some ware to stay wile the war was on.Even putting them and there familiesin danger they were always willing to help them. overall they were very coragous people.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Chiune was brave because he could of got hurt he was a very nice man and he risk his life for other people and they needid help and thats what he gave them and i say never ever give up.Monique's mom helped so much Jew's and she was a citisens to evry one she helped them escape from the Nazi and the Nazi were very mean and very rood and strong and monique's mom stood up for evryone.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Chiune was brave because he risked for life for other people. He disliked NaziÅ› and believed that Jews were great and nothing was wrong with them. He wrote more than 1000 visas to save other lives. Chiune really liked his family and he was a great person. No matter what he never gave up

    ReplyDelete
  30. Marcelle and Chiune are very similar. They are both determined to help Jews but help them in different ways. Chiune Sugihara wrote thousands of visas to help people get to other countries where they will be safe from the Zazis. Marcelle Solliage helped Jews by hiding them in her basement then taking them to different countries. They both put the Jews lives before their own and risk everything to get them to safety.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Chiune Sugihara and Marcelle Solliage are the same and different because they both helped many people in different ways. One sent them off to another place(Japan), while the other hid Jews in their basement. They were both risking everything they had, and were very corageous.

    ReplyDelete
  32. They both we silent leaders in WWll. They both helped many people but in different ways. Monique's mother stored people in her basement and Chiune wrote illegal visa's in order to help wanted Jews escape. Without people like these two WWll could have ended differently.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Marcelle and Sugihara both aided the jews attempting to get to safe countries. Sugihara issued thousands of visas, letting jews travel to safe places. Marcelle hid jews in a secret part of her cellar.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Chiune was a brave man. He helped the Jewish people even though he had betrayed his country. His country told him no three times but he still helped the people escape. Monique's mother was the same way. She helped Sevrine's family and many others escape from the Nazi's safely. They both were very helpful and both put their family at risk. Chiune got his whole family in prison but none of them cared. Monique's family was not caught for helping the Jews but both of them did a very good deed. They are both very brave people. They made a difference.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Chiune Sugihara and Marcelle Solliage are similar and different. They both had outstanding amounts of courage and bravery. They took risks that we may not even consider doing. Both helped Jews escape from devastating Nazi soldiers. Chiune helped hundreds of refugees escape from the deadly forces of the Nazi. Although Marcelle only helped 4 people extreme efforts were still needed to save the people in danger. Both people did actions that need recognition on all levels.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Chiune was a nice man to risk his life for Jew's. He wrote more than 1,000 visas for the Jew's to get out of Lithuania to get away from the Nazi. Chiune never gave up even though he lost his job. The whole family went to jail for 18 months but i think they did the right thing by helping the Jew's get away.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Marcelle and Chiune are very similar. They are both strong individuals who stood up against what some people thought was right to do what was TRULY right. Chiune issued all the Visas and Marcelle hid fugitive Jews in her basement, both in their Nazi-occupied country. Marcelle decided to risk her live when she transported the Jews, just as Chiune issued Visas against the Nazis AND his governments permission.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Chuine Sugihara and Marcelle Solliage are very different and very alike. They both helped Jews, but in different ways. Marcelle helped one family a ton and Chuine helped hundreds a little. I also think Marcelle had morre fun doing it than Chiune. Also, Chiune got caught and Marcelle didn't. But Marcelle's child and Chiune's child both became friends with a Jewish child. They are different and similar in many ways.

    ReplyDelete
  39. They are the same in many ways. One is that they helped the Jews into safe hiding. They both were against the Nazis. They helped the Jews get to safe countries by giving them Visas. That is why Marcell and Chunnie are the same.

    ReplyDelete
  40. They both dislike the Nazis. Marcelle helped Jewish people and protected them so the Nazis didn't get them. Chinue helped Jewish people escape. The difference is Chinue was from Lythumina and Marcelle was from France. Marcelle has a daughter,a only daughter while Chinue had sons. Marcelle's daughter was a friend to a Jewish girl,while Chinue's son also got to play with Jewish children.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Marcelle and Chiune both helped Jews escape Europe so they can be free.It is like a Underground Railroad and they helped Jews escape even though they knew if they were caught their family would be in a lot of trouble. Marcelle and Chiune are a like because they are brave and couragous.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Marcelle Solliage and Chiune Sugihara are different but have a few things in common. Chiune and Marcelle have 2 things in common the both helped more than one Jew and risk their family and their lives to help these people. Marcelle Solliage lives in Urup and lives with her daughter and Marcelle is a woman.She is very brave to give up her daughter's and her life. Chiune Sugihara lived in Japan with his wife and two sons. He disobeyed his govorment to save the Jews.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Marcelle and Chiune both helped Jewish people escape or get away from the Nazi. They were both very courageous and took risks to help other people like the Jews. Chiune did not care if his government told him not to sign the visas, He did it anyway because that is what he thought was right. Marcelle helped the Jewish family even though it was illegal. They both were two very courageous.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Both Marcelle Solliage and Chiune Sugihara are alike in many ways because they both did something helpful or caring. Chiune wrote all those visa´s for the jew´s escaping from Lithuania. Marcelle helped her daughter and Sevrine escaped from the Nazi´s. They both did something heroic to help someone they love or really care about

    ReplyDelete
  45. Marcelle and Chiune are alike because they both helped Jews get to other countries so they could live freely. Marcelle hid a Jewish family in her basement and helped them get out of the country. And when Chiune was in Lithuania, he sighned hundreds if visas so that the refugees could escape from Europe. Marcelle and Chiune were also different. While Marcelle hid Jews from the Nazis, Chiune gave the refugees visas so they could get out of Europe.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Marcelle and Chiune were two extraordinary people, who helped those in need. Marcelle and Chiune are similar and different in many different ways.

    Marcelle and Chiune helped Jewish people escape from the dreadful Nazi soldiers.They helped some Jews escape in time before the Nazis could find them. They both did something that was outlawed, and if they were caught, could bring them to camps, or even worse, kill them.

    Marcelle and Chiune did something similar, but in a different way. Marcelle only helped one person, and wasn't yelled at by the government. Chiune, however, was caught by the government, and was sent to jail along with his family for 18 months (1 year and 6 months). He also gave 300 people Visas to go through Japan to find another transport.

    Marcelle and Chiune were two encouraging people, and they helped the Jews toward the freedom we have today.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Both Marcelle Solliage and Chiune Sugihara were both brave people who helped Jews escape from the grasp of the horrifying Nazi. Marcelle took Sevrine to safety while others took her parents. Though the parents didn't survive, Marcelle saved Sevrine's life. Chiune though, signed many, many traveling visas for Jews who were also escaping from the Nazis. Everyday, he wrote visa after visa. He asked the government first, and they said no. He asked his government yet again, still they the answer no. He wrote the visas anyway. He said,"I may have to disobey my government, but I don't, I will be disobeying God." He did as he said and helped many Jews escape. Marcelle and Chiune both helped Jews through their hard times.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Chiune Sugihara and Marcelle Solliage both were very brave to help people that they didn't need to. And they risked their lives to help them. Chiune was very brave to write all those visa's to help Jews escape from the Nazi. Marcelle was also very brave to help lots of Jews by letting them hide in her home. They are very similar, but they also have some things that are different. Chiune asked his whole family help save the Jews. But Marcelle kept it a secret from everyone including her daughter. Chiune and Marcelle both worked really hard to save the Jews. Marcelle hid Jews in her house. While Chiune worked all day to write visa's to help the Jews. And they both made large risks to help the Jews escape from the Nazi. In conclusion, they both were very kind and brave to risk their lives to help people they didn't need to.

    ReplyDelete
  49. Chiune and Marcelle are similar and different in many ways. For one thing they both helped the Jewish but in different ways. Marcelle kept it a secret while Chiune and his family knew from the start.Another difference is Marcelle only helped a family or 2 while on the other hand Chiune helped hundreds of people. The final way that they are different is the way that they helped the Jewish Marcelle helped the Jewish more secretly sending them on the recistense while on the other hand Chiune wrote visas and let the whole country of Japan know. That is how they are similar and different.

    ReplyDelete
  50. They both helped Jews get to safety, but in very different ways. Marcelle hid people in her home and then transported them when the time was right. Instead of hiding people in his home Chiune gave out visas to Jewish refugees, so they could get to safety. They both were resistant to the Nazis.

    ReplyDelete
  51. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  52. They both hid Jews, and think the Nazi are doing the wrong thing. They may be different, but they both have the same cause. Chiune disobeyed his government. Well ,on the other hand, Marcelle risked her and her family's safety.

    ReplyDelete