Number the Stars (Chapters 5-6)
At the end of chapter 5, the author describes the Star of David being imprinted in Annemarie's palm. What do you think the author is really telling the readers as she describes the impression of the star in Annemarie's palm?
I think that the author is trying to describe how tightly Annemarie was holding the necklace.
ReplyDeleteYou might want to explain or add a little more. Nice job ! ;)
Deleteyou might want to put why she was holding it so tightly
DeleteThe star of David imprinted on her hand symbolized Ellen and it would go away after a little while like Ellen would eventually see her family again or leave some how.
ReplyDeleteI like the way you thought of that !
DeleteI like the way you thought of that !
Deletethank you
Deletesame
DeleteI think that the author was trying to describe that Annmarie was so scared she held the necklace very tightly. I think it was also trying to give a hint about the next chapter or up coming chapter.
ReplyDeletenice job :)
Deletegood job Chalotte
Deleteawww thank you ! :)
DeleteI think the authour is trying to tell us how tight Anne Marie was squeezing the necklace
ReplyDeleteThe Star imprinted on her hand symbolizes Ellen. Annemarie held the necklace tightly as if it was Ellen.
ReplyDeletewho is panda girl?
DeleteEmma's panda girl(I asked).
DeleteEmma's panda girl(I asked).
DeleteEmma's panda girl(I asked).
Deletehi i am landon
DeleteOps:(
DeleteI think the author was trying to describe how bad and frightning the soldiers were by showing how hard she was holding it and making it leave an imprint.
ReplyDeletenice thinking
DeleteI think the author was trying to describe how bad and frightning the soldiers were by showing how hard she was holding it and making it leave an imprint.
ReplyDeleteI think the author was trying to tell how scared Annemarie because she was holding the necklace so tight in her hand.
ReplyDeletesolid
DeleteI think the author is meaning how tight she was holding the Star of David. Maybe in a couple of chapters the Nazis would see this imprint on Annemaries hand and send her to a jew camp.
ReplyDeleteI think it shows us that annemarie likes Ellen that much and how scared she was that her best friend could be taken and she didn't want to loose another person in her life.
ReplyDeleteNo. 1
ReplyDeleteI describes that she was holding on so tightly because if the soldiers saw it she knew that they would take her.
That Ellen was holding the star very tightly because she was frightened and didn't want the soldier to see it.
ReplyDeleteThat Ellen was holding the star very tightly because she was frightened and didn't want the soldier to see it.
ReplyDeleteI think Annemarie didn't want her friend taken away and was really scared so she held on to it tightly.
ReplyDelete1 i think that the sogers will see the star on anmaries hand and think she is a jew and get taken
ReplyDeleteyou may want to say a little more:)
DeleteIt's soldiers and you might want to explain a liitle more ;)
DeleteIt made a mark because she was holding the star of david so tightly so the soldiers won't see it. \('.')/
ReplyDeleteYou might want to explain it more and reread the question but great job!
DeleteI think it shows just how much Annemarie wants the Rosens to be safe and how far she will go to save them.
ReplyDeleteI think that Annemarie is so nervous because she does not want her friend to get caught so she held it so tight that that it left an impression on her palm.
ReplyDeleteI think that Annemarie made the impression of the star on her hand so that she would be taken insteed of Ellen.
ReplyDeleteI think the author really means that Annemarie will help the Rosen's, which are Jewish. Also, the Star of David is the symbol for the Jewish.
ReplyDeleteI think the author described this because Annemarie was so scared and did not want the soldier to open her hand to see the star.
ReplyDeleteI think the author may have been forshadowing. Maybe she had the star imprint because she may have to pretend to be Jewish to save her friend's life.
ReplyDeleteI think Annemarie held the star or david so tightly because she did not Ellen to get caught. Now the impression is a symbol of their friendship.
ReplyDeleteIn a unexpected way it showed that Annmarie had helped a Jewish friend and would keep helping her friend and other Jews in danger.
ReplyDeleteAnmerie has the star of david imprinted in her hand because she might help the rosens and the symbol is for the Jews
ReplyDeleteI believe that Annemarie the author got the imprint to show that she was so scared about the solders. I also believe she did that so she would take the blame, not Ellen.
ReplyDeleteIn a unexpected way it showed that Annmarie had helped a Jewish friend and would keep helping her friend and other Jews in danger.
ReplyDeleteThe star being pressed into her palm represents how strong Annemarie´s love for Ellen is. It shows how far she might have to go to save her Jewish friend. This shows that the journey ahead, might not be what she expects.
ReplyDeleteI think that she was so nervous for Ellen that she clenched the necklace so hard it left an imprint. I also think that it was a clue to how for Annemarie would go to help her friend.
ReplyDeleteIt makes them in danger because a soldier could easily see the star of David and might think she is Jewish.
ReplyDeleteIf a soldier spots the imprint they will think she is Jew or they will think she is Ellen.
ReplyDeleteI think that the author really meant that she was so scared that the experience left an impression on her memory.
ReplyDeleteI think that the girls were nervous and they ripped the necalas and annemarie squesed it in her hand and made a imprant so that is a clue that annemarie wants to save her freind ellen
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think that the she wanted to discribe how scared Annemarie was when the soldiers came. And how much she wanted to help her friend in this postion.
ReplyDeleteIt shows how later in the story Annemarie would give up so much to help save Ellen from the Nazi soldiers.
ReplyDeleteI think the author added this to show how much Annmarie was afraid at that moment and how much she loved Ellen. I think this might also leave a clue to what will happen in the future to Annmarie and Ellen
ReplyDeleteI think that Annemarie was so scared that she griped it so hard which lefted the imprint of the star.
ReplyDeleteI think that they were saying how much mustle and how tight that she was holding it that it left a mark o her hand
ReplyDelete